| | |||||||
| Emotional Mastery Emotional intelligence, addiction and recovery, grieving, loss, fear, anger, guilt, resentment, frustration, anxiety, depression, happiness, joy, love, kindness, forgiveness, self-acceptance, confidence, escaping the pit of despair, EFT |
|
Welcome to the Personal Development for Smart People Forums, the place for lively, intelligent discussion of all personal growth issues -- physical, mental, financial, social, emotional, spiritual, and more. You're currently viewing as a guest, which gives you limited read-only access. By joining our free community, you'll be able to post your own messages, access many members-only features, see the new messages posted since your last visit, and of course remove this header message. Registration is fast, simple, and free, so please join today. If you arrived here from a search engine, you may want to explore the main site first, which includes hundreds of deep and insightful articles on a variety of personal development topics. |
| | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
| | #1 (permalink) |
| Senior Member Join Date: Dec 2006
Posts: 212
|
I moved back to the house where I grew up. My grandfather, who is 83, has missed and worried about me severely for several years, so he's ecstatic. Also, I have to bail my sister out of the financial mess she's created; she has the mortgage to the house (my grandfather sold it to her in a moment of panic), yet has never paid the note- meaning that my grandfather has paid $60,000 for HER house over the last 4 years. I have the upstairs apartment where my grandparents and I used to live. My task is to clean it out, sell whatever is salable on Ebay (a great jumpstart to my store), and start renovations. I'm also helping my grandfather learn how to use the computer and go on the Internet. He's very happy, my sister is probably deeply relieved, and I'm not feeling so good about myself. I just moved from a gorgeous, wealthy neighborhood where we didn't even lock our doors to a complete ghetto environment where we bar the doors at night. I could wander to Whole Foods and the supermarket at 9:45 PM and not even think about it; now, I have to watch my back if I leave the house at 2 PM. Plus, this house holds so many bad memories for me. It's the place where my mother died, where I was sexually abused (touched the wrong way and leered at as a child, etc), and I was driven from my home after my mother died. I always lived in fear, here, because my sister was nuts and would verbally abuse me. Therefore, I was eternally on the defensive, with very strong walls put up. When I was in the first neighborhood, I was able to open up to abundance in such a way that I could ask for something and it would literally show up within 24 hours, with practically no exceptions. It was amazing. My life felt so blessed. Now, I'm here, and I feel just...blocked up. My meditation, once clear and easy, is now full of jumbled thoughts that are hard to put to rest. I feel like I've regressed, to a degree, but at the same time I don't, because I finally have my own place. I'm running out of money, yet can't get my sense of self-discipline back. I'm thinking of dropping the blog because I can't get myself to write. My other site is foundering, because I'm so frustrated with trying to teach myself code, Dreamweaver, Fireworks, and Photoshop so that I get something professional-looking and credible to even sell from. I have great fiction ideas, but can't tear myself away from mindless computer fluff long enough to write them- plus, fiction won't make me immediate money, so why bother? I'm also having issues with self-care. When I went to the store yesterday, I made myself not accept my grandfather's offer of a ride, just so I could go out on my own schedule, take my time, and go where I wanted. He's instilled a fear of my neighborhood in me since I was a child which I'm trying to get away from (I've lived in a part of Brooklyn that's way worse than where I am now), but it's hard. I got my eyebrows done yesterday, something that I used to do in the better neighborhood, and I felt so good! Yet, things like washing and getting my hair done or doing my nails are a huge chore that I stall and stall on...even though they were par for the course in the better town. I'm definitely NOT an employee. No, no, no. You all know that |
| | |
| | #3 (permalink) |
| Senior Member Join Date: Dec 2006
Posts: 305
|
Kali, The problem with this, and with your other post especially is that you don't leave much room for anything but sympathy, and sympathy just makes all your troubles seem more real and valid and harder to escape from. Most of the people here understand that to pat you on the back and tell you how hard done by you are will just make it worse and disempower you even more. I will run the risk of offending you and attempt to help. re Clinical depression :- I was diagnosed CD when i was in my early teens. Fought to be in control of my mind and emotions for four years without medication, won, and am now pretty much free of it. It can be done. *patiently waits for the 'But mine is different', 'you just don't understand how hard it is' etc. * I would take a quick look over your posts, all you are focussing on is how bad things are. -I- started to feel down reading them. If this is what you are thinking all day no wonder you are depressed. I can find at least 6 negative affirmations in your other post and dozens in this one. If you weren't depressed before you wrote them I can assure you, you would have been after them. Before you berate me, please write a post about how good everything is in your life, then see how you feel. e.g. You don't live in Bhagdad where you have about a 60%+ of dying everytime you leave your house. Or Africa, where your problem would be finding three things to eat, not 3 computer programs to learn. At least 2/3 of the world's population would give everything they have to swap lives with you without thinking twice. $50 bet if you write that post you will feel better (until you start thinking about the bad again) I promise in front of everyone here that I will pay your paypal account $50 US if you put in the effort to write a positive post and recieve no benefit whatsoever from it. At least you can afford to get your hair and/or nails done then. If you refuse to write the positive post, i.e. refuse to make any attempt to feel better, then you are effectively saying that you want to be depressed. Life is sometimes tough. Today it's yours, 6 months ago it was mine. If you dwell on it too much it will stay that way. If you turn around, it WILL come good. *insert pantene shampoo ad here* (who gets that one?) re Sites :- If you want help making your site look good, look for a partner who is a geek and would prefer to build than write, and do a profit share. e.g. I put up a post yesterday that I can make pretty sites but I need people to give me the content. Why didn't you reply to that? If your site doesn't make money then at least you didn't lose any, because you only have to pay me when you make some. If you sort yourself out I would be happy to work with you. I have a decent amount of respect for you from what I have seen you say in these forums so far. I will forgive these two posts. I almost had a spat attack recently myself. Yes you are in a pit, I understand, and give a bit of sympathy for that. Wallowing in it will keep you there, for that you get no sympathy. It isn't easy I know, but if you don't stop talking about how bad it is you will only make it harder. A. Write the positive post, earn your $50, then abuse me for how your depression and situation is special and I just don't understand how hard it is. Or B. write it, feel better, find someone to help you with your sites, (me or another doesn't matter) and make a lot more than $50, then get out of the dingy neighborhood, taking your grandfather with you. You might even have enough change to put your sister into counselling, and get a lawyer for the house.
__________________ *NEW*Rantcrunch.com Angry? Upset? Furious? - Just get it off your chest. Mami Yamazaki - A quest to get a date with a Japanese model Website Crunch - Making Website dreams happen for those who don't know how. Secret Scrolls - LoA & Life Coaching Blog Last edited by Dani; 02-15-2007 at 08:10 AM. |
| | |
| | #4 (permalink) |
| Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2006 Location: Detroit
Posts: 772
|
These words may not exactly be kind, but it seems like what you need to hear: It’s Your Fault That You Feel Bad! Remember, you control your environment, not vice versa. You're stronger than this and will pull through and be a better, stronger person for it.
__________________ A truly open mind will seriously consider all points of view, even those with which it strongly disagrees for there may be a grain of truth in even the most ridiculous of opinions. |
| | |
| | #5 (permalink) |
| Member Join Date: Feb 2007
Posts: 35
|
Hi Kali Can identify with a lot of stuff ur saying.. am in a troubling situation myself.. but try hard to be and think positive everyday... Hey i don't even have a bedroom on my own rite Now!! Thoughts are living things and what we think grows... so keep trying to think positive and things will change... hope u like this : |
| | |
| | #6 (permalink) |
| Senior Member Join Date: Dec 2006
Posts: 212
|
OK, so the moral of the story in this is that I should be kicking myself for being depressive, and that it's just all in my head, and how silly I am for making the situation. As someone who has battled depression for a good chunk of her life, and has helped others through it, one of the worst things you can say to a clinically depressive person is that it's all their fault. I should have kept my fingers shut. (And an honest thank you to janlee.) ETA: quotes from someone else about their depression. Pretty much sums things up for me as well. And while I fully respected the intelligence and expertise of the doctor I began to see, he could base his diagnosis only on the subjective information I was giving him. It wasn't his fault he thought I was depressed; it was mine. Last edited by Isis Kali; 02-15-2007 at 09:47 PM. |
| | |
| | #7 (permalink) |
| Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2006 Location: Detroit
Posts: 772
|
I'm sorry you misunderstood, but the point of my posting was that YOU control how you react to a situation. Your situation should not control you. Nothing more.
__________________ A truly open mind will seriously consider all points of view, even those with which it strongly disagrees for there may be a grain of truth in even the most ridiculous of opinions. |
| | |
| | #8 (permalink) |
| Legendary Member | Isis Kali, I would like to invite you to look again for the love that's contained in the responses to your post. Also, you might want to read your own posts to see what kind of response they invite. The main messages I heard in your original post were "I can't" and "I need" -- and I'll bet you're aware by now that the posters here don't tend to support those metamessages. We support the abundance of vitality, power, love and peace that we know are possibilities within you. Dani wrote to you with an incredibly generous offer of coaching, inspiration and even money. Matthew Shea directed you to some of Steve's writing, intending to remind you of your own bountiful power. Rather than being grateful, you first reacted a little petulantly when you didn't get any responses as quickly as you 'needed', and then a little more petulantly when you got responses that weren't in line with what you 'needed'. You were so right to post here, I think, because it gives you the chance to see a little microcosm of what may be happening in your life. Do you think that's possible? People tend to find what they're looking for; maybe this whole episode is an invitation from the universe to examine what and how you're seeking. Lots of love and loads of power to you, angela |
| | |
| | #9 (permalink) | |
| Senior Member Join Date: Dec 2006
Posts: 212
| Quote:
Plus, MS' link actually go to a forum post that doesn't reference one of Steve articles. I read it already. I guess what I'm saying...and what I do in practice...is that I don't go the "Tough Love" route, especially when I recognize where someone's coming from in terms of depression. It backfires most of the time, and is generally a bad idea. They may not like those words in the forums generally, but sometimes people need to have a space to say those things...and they simply need someone to say, "I understand. You'll feel better. We're listening." Not "Well, don't you know it's your fault? Why don't you do thisthisthis?" I'm regretting posting because all I'm hearing is that I'm not doing things right, I'm not receiving correctly, I'm wrong, I'm bad. That's what this all feels like to me. It's making me very, very upset right now, and I don't especially want to come back to this thread. I wish I could erase it. Last edited by Isis Kali; 02-15-2007 at 10:14 PM. | |
| | |
| | #10 (permalink) | |
| Legendary Member | Quote:
Have you considered that things had been too easy for you, and maybe you attracted some big challenges into your life so you could really spread your wings and feel your own huge power? Just food for thought. Now, the universe is knocking on your head trying to heap benefit upon you, and you are telling it, "Ouch!! Quick knocking on my head!" | |
| | |
| | #11 (permalink) | |
| Senior Member Join Date: Dec 2006
Posts: 305
| Quote:
Please read my post again. I said none of those things. You might be seeing them in my post but that's not what I said. I spoke very straightforward yes, but you don't need to feel ashamed. I went through it myself. Also look over your own posts, you already set yourself up to defend against these 'it's all in your head' posts, you even predicted they were coming! Going LOA style you intended these responses, and you probably had your response post already sitting in your head before any of us even read your initial ones. You put us in a difficult situation. You basically said with your posts don't reply unless you are going to sympathise with me. But you want help? Sympathy does not help you, it -weakens- you. Besides, if it really was chemical and you had no control whatsoever, then no words we say can have any effect positive or negative. If our words can affect you, positive or negative, then you have at least a little control because we all know that outside circumstances only affect us when we let them. Your posts also highlighted all the bad things in your life, and how you feel terrible after leaving your great life to go backwards to your old life. If it is these circumstances that are making you feel bad then again it's not chemical it's circumstantial. You cannot say - It is chemical and I, who am inside my head, have no control, but life, which is outside my head, has complete control of my emotions????? You do realise the impossibility of that statement don't you? Anyway I know lecturing you won't change your mind. "A person convinced against their will, is of the same opinion still!" So I will quadruple the offer. $200 US If you can write a several hundred word positive post and not fell better. It is sitting in my paypal account right now with your name on it. That will get your hair and your nails done, and you even take Grandpa out to dinner. Prove to us it is out your control. I also offerred to help you with your money and computer program stress. You threw the offer back in my face without even commenting on it. Do you really want help with these things or to just complain about them? If you just wanted to vent then SAY THAT. Don't ask for help then reject everything people offer you and take a swing at them in the process. If you can't show us you want to try to get out of the depression by at least taking my challenge, then why would any of us want to help you, when you don't want to help yourself? Do the challenge and prove me wrong, or forever hold your peace. -completely off topic but you obviously have a lot of pent up anxiety and pain attached to your youth, this could be the perfect opportunity to work through that pain, and free yourself from it leavign you stronger and happier than ever before.
__________________ *NEW*Rantcrunch.com Angry? Upset? Furious? - Just get it off your chest. Mami Yamazaki - A quest to get a date with a Japanese model Website Crunch - Making Website dreams happen for those who don't know how. Secret Scrolls - LoA & Life Coaching Blog Last edited by Dani; 02-16-2007 at 12:35 AM. | |
| | |
| | #12 (permalink) | |
| Senior Member | Quote:
I've gone through some fairly significant personal trials over the past few years, including a divorce. I've had my own "depressive episodes" but I've eventually realized what everyone is trying to tell you--that your perception defines your reality. I've been amazed and the difference a simple change in perception has made in my own life--just putting a positive "spin" on my troubles has made them easier to deal with. I know that when you're in the midst of a depressive episode that's the last thing you want to hear, but its the truth. The longer and deeper you allow yourself to wallow in your own despair the worse things get. At the very least you should consider yourself fortunate that you've got a number of people--most, if not all, whom have never met you--who care about what your going through. You can say that they're not understanding or not telling you the right thing, but just the fact that these people are there is something positive that you can build from.
__________________ THE SAVAGE SCIENCE--MMA, mayhem and more!! http://www.thesavagescience.com THE SAVAGE SCIENCE BLOG--up-to-the minute MMA news and intelligent commentary: http://blog.thesavagescience.com | |
| | |
| | #13 (permalink) |
| Member Join Date: Jan 2007
Posts: 61
|
Your environment is full of bad energy and is quickly destroying you. Between all the bad experiences, death, and other events that took place in this house, no wonder you feel so bad. I would suggest you move back on your own to the new life you had created that was full of positive energy. Your sister owns the property, not you, so you gain nothing from doing any work on it. You said she treated you badly all your life, so why put yourself in the situation again. There is so much negative memories, energy, events, etc in this area/house, the only way for you to regain your health and sanity is get out as you did before.
|
| | |
| | #14 (permalink) | |
| Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2006
Posts: 525
|
I know the feeling, believe me, for I am a child of Saturn also. I also know the feeling of growing up with a lot of fear and sexual abuse in a dark house in a dark and scary neighborhood. I know the layers and layers of rock-like stuff that lays down in you. I know how much better I feel when I am away from heavy environments, and I know how it all comes back like a ton of bricks when I come back to them. I also know the gifts of Saturn, and I know that you shall know them too, in your time. And I think that you would not, at length, trade them for any amount of what the world calls success. Others may advice you to cheer yourself up. I say, "when in deep water, become a diver." "When fishermen can't fish, they mend nets." "Consider the uses of adversity." Feel it all, stay with it, unpack it and you will find that your darkness is full of information and wisdom. Don't be in a hurry, your soul knows what it is doing. I wish you all good things. You are on my buddy list, by the way. This is from Thomas Moore's Care of the Soul: Quote:
Megan Last edited by Megan; 02-16-2007 at 05:42 AM. | |
| | |
| | #15 (permalink) | |
| Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2006
Posts: 525
| Quote:
Be blessed, all of you. Last edited by Megan; 02-16-2007 at 05:51 AM. | |
| | |
| | #16 (permalink) | |
| Moderator Join Date: Nov 2006
Posts: 1,329
| Quote:
Her financial problems are her responsibility. To take on her problems is to be a martyr. You won't get any thanks or return for your money or your hard work renovating the house. What do you get out of sorting out her mess? If you changed the thought, "I have to bail my sister out", to "My sister is responsible for bailing herself out, I will support her emotionally but not financially should she choose to take that step." What difference would that make to your life? Oh yes - and MOVE HOUSE! You're not happy, you don't want to be there, find somewhere else! Contrary to popular opinion on this site: having a day job that pays the rent is not the end of the world if it means you are able to be happy living in a place that is good for you.
__________________ My new blog: The Self Confident Soul. I would love your comments Twitter: Follow Me | |
| | |
| | #17 (permalink) |
| Senior Member |
Dear Isis Kali, I agree that you need to move unless you can quickly control the spell this house has you under. While I understand the concept that some people have expressed here, sometimes you feel too bowed down to feel positive. It soudns like moving there has stirred up many unhappy memories for you. Why put yourself in that situation? What is the arrnagement under which you've moved there? I understand that your Grandfather is happy to have you there, but it sounds like you are putting others' needs before your own. Is there some way you can relieve your Grandfather's distress without causing any distress for you? I'm with HolisticStar about your sister... Surely there can be a way that you can have a better life through this tho? I agree thinking positively can help and all, but it sounds like the place is psychically oppressive for you. Be kind and loving to yourself first. You can't care for others (your Grandfather) unless you are well. So get yourself well again and see what you can do then. Much love to you Hazel
__________________ Learn EFT and change your life today! http://www.reallygoodideas.com.au hazelb@reallygoodideas.com.au |
| | |
| | #18 (permalink) |
| Senior Member |
__________________ Learn EFT and change your life today! http://www.reallygoodideas.com.au hazelb@reallygoodideas.com.au |
| | |
| | #19 (permalink) |
| Member Join Date: Feb 2007
Posts: 35
|
Hi Kali Please dont give up coming to the forums, loads of people do care about u here and wish u well. All the advice is given with love... it is hard to know what is going on in peoples' minds.. none of us can know that and we shouldnt judge people - we dont have the right to do that. I wish u well in ur efforts to cope with ur depression, do whatever feels right to u... maybe having someone to talk to - counselling - might help. I know it helps me. Whether ur depression is chemically related or not doesn't really matter, and we can never measure ourselves against others .. thats not the way... we can only look at ourselves, see where we are in life and look for ways to deal with things. I have suffered from depression all my life (am now 50) and my bro committed suicide at 18 (30 yrs ago now) because he was depressed. I never took any antidepressants until last Nov when my life completely exploded... my ex was arrested for abusing 2 boys we used to care for.. i had to move countries and live at my sis's flat now.. everything has gone.. but I am still here and i have to deal with the fallout.. I have no contact with my ex as I am going to be a witness for the prosecution... we were tog 17 yrs and it was v hard for me to believe he had done it. But i believe kids dont lie.. and after being sexually abused himself u'd think he'd know better.. I was abused in every way as a kid, and i couldnt imagine going back to that house - it must be a nightmare scenario for u.. I couldnt go back anyway cos its been demolished.. but even driving past the area gives me the creeps.. so how u r living there i don't know. U must be a very strong person inside.. Sometimes life throws stuff at us.. it doesn't really matter what it is .. its how we deal with it.. and u know what, only U, know how to deal with it... take care, and i wish u all the very best in whatever U decide to do.. love and light janlee x PS Quote from Carl Jung: Everything that irritates us about others can lead us to an understanding of ourselves. Last edited by janlee; 02-16-2007 at 01:45 PM. Reason: to add something |
| | |
| | #20 (permalink) |
| Member |
I'm sad for you Isis. I was in the same predicament which, and hate to say, I created for my higher fullfillment/learning/accomplishing. All of your posts were so in-sight-full - Janlee - hats off to you - I had suffered from CD as well and had to live for awhile in my mother's condo after she committed suicide from CD her whole life and just couldn't do it - after taking major loss and almost giving it away I'm better off in the little studio by myself and dealing w/certain (a lot) of issues of mine that I'm so done with. Isis, it's hard to move past the burdens that seem to be thrown at you leaving you in a tail spin which only attracts more as, how can it not for it's inevitable to focus on what you had and what you have. YOU MUST take back your control and focus on what would make you feel better w/yourself and safer. Too many negative irons in the fire and you're overwhelmed, I can understand. Baby steps? Sounds easy, but, you've GOT to move on anyway you can - ATTRACT ppl that will help you, like the ppl here in this awsome forum for starters - then human angels..... so to speak, will guide you out of this palace filled with past haunts - be in home/mind/body. You'll be in my positive/energy/lvg thoughts.... LOA!
|
| | |
| | #21 (permalink) |
| Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2006 Location: Reno/Tahoe, NV, USA
Posts: 375
|
Isis, You are an obviously intelligent, compassionate, wonderful woman. You're a great writer too -- I really like your blog! What you need to do is take care of yourself. You're being too hard on yourself, trying to make yourself happy in an environment that obviously isn't for you. Some places give us power; other places take that power away. I found that out when my boyfriend and I made the long-anticipated move from Reno to San Francisco, somewhere he's always wanted to live! We were a 15 minute walk away from work, had a full panoramic view of the Golden Gate, had the best sushi, Indian and Greek food all within three blocks of us. It was a dream come true. But... He was miserable. We spent two years there as he finished school. Those two years nearly broke his spirit. You know what started him on the road to recovery? Deciding to move back to Reno. As soon as he made that decision, things started to get better. Then we moved, and within three months, he lost 30 lbs of depression weight, reconnected with his friends and family, went from jobless to making $50K a year, and started wearing dockers and sweaters instead of sweatpants and hoodies. What you're doing for your family is a wonderful and amazing thing, but if the place that you're in isn't conducive to your energy, you need to leave. This is for your own emotional & spiritual wellbeing, as well as your own financial wellbeing -- because you're self-employed, you can't lose all motivation and still make money by showing up at the office for 8 hours a day. And, you'll save disappointment to devoted readers of your blog, who will miss you if you lose the drive to keep writing. Hugs to you!
__________________ ~ Elaine. |
| | |
| | #22 (permalink) |
| Junior Member Join Date: Nov 2006
Posts: 19
|
Im gonna go out on a limb here and take a different approach to your situation than others have. I hope you are still in the hope mindset and are continuing to check this thread. One of the things that i have come to believe about depression (through mine) is that it is anger turned inward. So ask yourself, what are you angry at yourself or others for? Are you angry that your sister's financial mess and the feeling that you must fix it? Are you angry that you are back at the house where there is so much pain? Are you angry at yourself for feeling you have to take care of your grandfather? Its not as easy as people say to just start thinking positive and everything will change for the better. From a law of attraction standpoint, it seems to be a common occurance that we are brought back to a place where we feel there is unfinished business or pain because we feel we havent conquered it yet. One of the most powerful practices is that of forgiveness. You have to forgive that fact that your sister is in the situation she is, you have to forgive that you were abused, and you have to forgive yourself for being afraid of that house in the past and today. You will not notice any significant difference until you start practicing this. Loving forgiveness is the most important step. The next step is try to think positively, as others said, this will help dramatically as well. your statement here shows that you are trying and seeing the bright side of things: "I have the upstairs apartment where my grandparents and I used to live. My task is to clean it out, sell whatever is salable on Ebay (a great jumpstart to my store), and start renovations. I'm also helping my grandfather learn how to use the computer and go on the Internet. He's very happy, my sister is probably deeply relieved" Try and focus on creating mental statements like this. You will find that by getting closer to your sister and your grandfather, your sense of peace will change greatly. However, make sure you still have time for yourself. Your meditation will change back as well, after some time. Cant say that I know what its like getting my eyebrows done (cause im a guy) but little things like this can make a big difference as well (so ive heard). You said he is afraid of his neighborhood, and has made you feel that way. Show him that you are not afraid, he will change and so will you. Put up a negativity wall (as i say) and do not allow things to enter. Remember that your inner thoughts reflect your outside reality. Use your heart as your guide and know that you are being selfless in taking on these tasks. Know that you are helping people tremendously. After visiting your blog it seems like your passion is writing and expression and i think it would be a big mistake to give it up. It probably wouldnt hurt to write more about your current experience, it will help to release some of those feelings and relate to others through personal experience (they love that). Alot of great books were written during great personal struggle and discovery. I wouldnt give up on your writing fiction either, if you write short storys or ebooks, you can post them right on your blog and either sell them or offer them for free to gain traffic (seems you've started to do this). The title of your blog is "Love, sex, relationships, and self development for the fearless thinker". Will you allow yourself to be fearless or controlled by fear? Use this time to create new relationships with your grandfather and your sister, use it to release things that have been troubling you, use it to get over your fear of that house, use it to jumpstart your ebay store (as you said), use it to increase your writing capabilities, use it to grow. You never know what may come of this but this hard time for you might yield more than one great result. Just try not to tackle everything in one day because then you will be overwhelmed, pace yourself. I wish you the best. |
| | |
| | #23 (permalink) |
| Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2006
Posts: 512
|
This whole post has made me think quite a bit. First, I have to agree with what Dani posted way in the beginning. But it also made me think about whether people want to be given support, or an answer, or if they just want to be heard. I think that all those different reasons for posting are valid. I think that it's not always beneficial to jump in with a "this is what you need to do." At any rate, Dani, it seems that you're in a very trying period. You're not where you want to be. All of us can understand that feeling, and we all do wish you well. Good luck. |
| | |
| | #24 (permalink) | |
| Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2006
Posts: 525
|
I think Max Weber talks about the work ethic that came out of Protestantism and has infected, as it were, Western civilization. It's simply never OK for us to be where we are if that place is not "productive." I think we need to get over that. People who have been abused need a safe place to work things through. All she asked for were some kind words, folks. I think it makes us feel anxious to just be with someone in pain. Why is that? Maybe we're making a slave-driving religion out of self improvement? Quote:
Last edited by Megan; 02-18-2007 at 02:37 PM. | |
| | |
| | #25 (permalink) | |
| Legendary Member | Quote:
The very kind words offered in response to Isis' post were oozing with love and support, but it wasn't the normal, "oh, you poor thing, you must really be suffering, you're doing the best you can...." poo poo. That kind of comfort and nurturing is what you get from your girlfriends or your mother, the people who support wallowing as an ordinary way to get through tough times. If you're asking for help, you're not just BEING with your pain. Wallowing is great, don't get me wrong. But when you get to the point where you're ready to ask people who are committed to personal development for THEIR support, you'd better be ready for the extraordinary support that's provided by this world: being reminded of your power, that you're 100% responsible for your life, and that there's lots of love and resources here for you if you are willing to open yourself to it and let go of the stuff that's not working for you. Personal development is not a "slave-driving religion;" you and I and Isis Kali and completely free. If we come to this remarkable group of people here looking for support, it's reasonable to expect that we'll be reminded of and encouraged in our own extraordinary possibilities. | |
| | |
| | #27 (permalink) | |
| Senior Member | Quote:
Now we have people defensively arguing that the real problem is that Isis Kali simply doesnt know good advice when she sees it. It seems that even in a personal development forum, the principle can precede the person (i.e. its more important to be right, than to empathise with the other persons feelings.) Its difficult to know exactly what state someone is in, or exactly what sort of support they're looking for based on a brief, written post. And I truly believe that everyone sincerely tried their best to help. But evidently, they missed the mark and thats no-ones fault. Lets move on. | |
| | |
| | #28 (permalink) |
| Legendary Member |
Indeed, let's move on, but I would like to point out that the folks who offered loving and supportive words in response to a request from Isis Kali for loving and supportive words, missed no mark. There was no lack of compassion in this thread, only love and generosity.
|
| | |
| | #29 (permalink) |
| Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2006 Location: Detroit
Posts: 772
|
Isis has been on the boards, but has apparently chosen to abandon this thread. For the record, though, I feel bad that I failed to fully explain myself in my post above. Looking back on her original post, I should have been more understanding, not tried to give a kick in the pants as I did. I won't go so far as to retract what I said as I think the message is true, but it wasn't an appropriate response here. This thread has gotten me thinking, though, that internet forums in general are becoming an increasing distraction for me and are allowing me to spend more and more time away from work and other things that I should be doing. If I keep up at this rate, it will start to affect my life in real ways (although it hasn't yet done so). I'll still read Steve's blog, but I cannot spend any more time here on the forums. If anyone sees me around, please send me a PM and yell at me (seriously).
__________________ A truly open mind will seriously consider all points of view, even those with which it strongly disagrees for there may be a grain of truth in even the most ridiculous of opinions. |
| | |
| | #30 (permalink) |
| Senior Member Join Date: Nov 2006
Posts: 525
|
...on the contrary, I believe everyone truly wanted to help, which is wonderful. When I lost my son, people were likewise wonderful. My housemate cooked for me for an entire month; another friend sent me to a spa. But the same friend who cooked for me also said to me three weeks after he died, "You're grieving too long." Another friend said to me about that time, "You need to laugh more." It felt like a form of violence, and I just withdrew because that's all I was capable of at the time. So I had the overwhelming grief of losing a son, and the trauma of friends who meant well, but couldn't stay with their own discomfort in the presence of deep pain. I have a tape set by Stephen and Ondrea Levine called To Love and Be Loved: The Difficult Yoga of Relationship. In it they speak of "swimming in the ocean of each other's grief." That is a difficult assignment, but one which life will eventually require from us if we continue to grow, I think. And isn't continuing to grow what Personal Development is all about? I don't think we should be in a hurry to move Isis Kali on, or to move on from this topic. There's a lot to unpack here, I think. But only if we want to. But you, Matthew, better move on, or I'm gonna hafta yell atcha! |
| | |
| Bookmarks |
« Previous Thread
|
Next Thread »
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | |
| |
| | ||||
| Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
| Ask And Ye Shall Receive... | Love Angel | Character & Contribution | 17 | 03-30-2007 10:50 PM |
| How to remember more words of foreign language quickly | jeff-wang | Personal Effectiveness | 10 | 02-16-2007 01:53 AM |
| A picture is worth a 1000 words | rock1000 | Character & Contribution | 18 | 12-09-2006 03:19 AM |
| What kind of music do you listen to?? | Trina | General & Introductions | 28 | 11-26-2006 10:24 PM |
| Actions vs. Words | pi11 | Social & Relationships | 10 | 11-05-2006 05:20 PM |
All times are GMT. The time now is 12:42 AM.






