Really interesting thread - I've not seen such a subject discussed and debated without devolving into flaming in a very long time
It's important, especially that even in divergent views there seems to be intent to be intellectually open and honest. Good on you!
Yes, I've got to agree with the points about the axioms being flawed, or at least incomplete. They're implanting views on the nature of physics, 'ghosts' and how they interact which people/'this world.' I have good faith that you fully intend to examine the question fairly, but with these premises, it doesn't encompass what supposed believers necessarily believe.