Gratitude
January 22nd, 2007 by Steve Pavlina
Email this article to a friend
Gratitude equals wealth. Wealth equals gratitude. You’ve probably heard one of those expressions before… or at least something similar. Certainly the connection seems true on an internal, emotional level. It’s hard to imagine feeling wealthy without also being grateful. And if you’re truly grateful, you probably feel wealthy as well, regardless of your actual circumstances.
Because of this apparent connection between wealth and gratitude, many so-called wealth experts suggest that if you want to increase your wealth, you should focus on being more grateful. This sounds pretty good on the surface and meshes well with the Law of Attraction. The idea is that by feeling more grateful, you’ll feel more wealthy and thereby attract more abundance into your life.
Having tested this for myself extensively, I found there was an effective way to practice gratitude and an ineffective way. Unfortunately, the ineffective way is much more obvious, and I was stuck with that form of gratitude for many years. But eventually I progressed towards a deeper understanding of gratitude and found a more effective way to practice it, one that yielded much greater external abundance as well.
First, I’ll address the ineffective form of gratitude. Let’s call it Level 1 Gratitude. This is gratitude for your possessions and your immediate circumstances. It’s the kind of gratitude we learn as children: Thank you for the gift, for the candy, for the trip to park, etc. When you practice this as an adult, it spawns thoughts of gratitude for things like:
- a roof over your head
- your material possessions
- a car that runs
- your health
- your relationships
- your family
- your job
- your skills
- the holidays
Note that Level 1 Gratitude goes beyond material possessions. It’s the default form of gratitude you’re likely to come up with when you attempt to make a list of things to be grateful for.
I’m not suggesting there’s anything bad or wrong with this form of gratitude. It’s certainly better than having thoughts of scarcity. However, in terms of activating the Law of Attraction, its effectiveness is relatively weak.
Often when people attempt to use Level 1 Gratitude, it’s because they’re actually feeling complacent or negative about their circumstances, but they’re trying to look on the bright side and build some positive momentum. If you’ve ever expressed gratitude by starting with the words “at least,” you know what I mean. At least I have my health. At least I have a roof over my head. At least I have a vacation coming up.
The underlying message is: What I have is OK, and I can temporarily feel grateful about it if I push myself to do so, but genuine gratitude isn’t my default feeling because ultimately my circumstances just aren’t that exciting. More often than not, they leave me feeling empty or complacent rather than grateful.
When I choose to do so, I can notice my life circumstances and feel grateful for them. I can feel grateful for my marriage, my kids, my house, my career, my friendships and so on. The essence of the experience is no different than when I found myself in far less abundant circumstances.
Even when your overall circumstances seem negative, you can still temporarily pop into a state of Level 1 Gratitude just by changing your focus. For some people this can be the catalyst for a major attitude change, but in most situations it only provides a temporary reprieve with no major lasting benefit.
The reason Level 1 Gratitude usually fails to trigger the Law of Attraction is that Level 1 is too weak. It’s like drinking synthehol – it has no bite. You can enjoy this state of gratitude temporarily, but overall you’ll remain stuck in your old patterns. Level 1 Gratitude is fragile since all it takes to knock you out of state is a change in circumstances or a change in your focus. Even getting the mail can kill it.
Let’s proceed to Level 2 Gratitude. I think of this as “holistic gratitude” because it’s independent of situations and circumstances. This is a feeling of gratitude for life itself, for existence, for anything and everything you experience. But rather than being a temporary emotion that requires constant focus, Level 2 Gratitude is more of an underlying attitude. With practice it becomes part of your identity.
Level 2 Gratitude encompasses everything in Level 1, but Level 2 goes beyond that to include being grateful for:
- your life
- the universe
- time and space
- your problems, challenges, and hardships
- your foibles and mistakes
- your consciousness
- your ego
- people who treat you unkindly or unfairly
- your thoughts and emotions
- your freedom of choice
- ideas and concepts
Level 2 Gratitude says, “How wonderful it is to exist!” Circumstances are irrelevant because this form of gratitude is a choice that needs no justification. It is a sense of utter fascination with the very notion of existence.
You become grateful for the adventure that is life, including all of its twists and turns. This form of gratitude is synonymous with unconditional love because there is no attachment to circumstances or outcomes. Consequently, there is no fear of loss or change.
Level 2 Gratitude is like having a constant echo in the back of your consciousness saying, “Wow!” Everything else is experienced on top of that Wow. Gratitude becomes the canvas upon which your life is painted.
Perhaps the closest analogy I can offer is to imagine playing a video game. The game is totally state-of-the-art. You’re amazed by the graphics, the music, the gameplay, the characters, etc. It doesn’t matter so much if you win or lose because the experience itself is what draws you in. You’re so fascinated by the nature of the experience that the details are secondary.
If you can remain in that state of wonder, you’re likely to perform well at the game and enjoy the experience. Eventually you’ll get good at it. Your glorious accumulations may include a high-level avatar, tons of gold, and alliances with other characters. But that stuff is only the result of your enjoyment, not the cause of it. The game can still be fun even when you’re just starting out and have no meaningful possessions. In some games you can even go deep into debt, and yet the experience is still fun.
For more on the whole “life is a game” concept, be sure to read Life - The Ultimate Game. Many people find this analogy helpful for getting past fear and loosening their death-grip attachment to circumstances. Letting go of this conditional attachment is the key to experiencing Level 2 Gratitude.
When you feel grateful for existence itself, you move from doing grateful to being grateful. At this level you finally activate the Law of Attraction because you’re broadcasting gratitude all the time. It becomes part of your identity. Ultimately you attract circumstances that resonate with who you are.
When your feelings of gratitude are conditional upon temporary circumstances like your stuff, your job, and your relationships, your base identity doesn’t change. But when you root your gratitude in something permanent, it becomes a permanent part of you. Instead of saying, “I am grateful for…” you just say, “I am grateful.”
I must have spent at least 10 years practicing Level 1 Gratitude (mostly in vain) before I began shifting towards Level 2. It was a very gradual process as my feelings of gratitude became more unconditional. It started with me attempting to feel grateful for things I wouldn’t normally feel grateful for, like my breathing, the bushes on the street, music, my biggest failures, etc. This helped me see that no matter how negative, meaningless, or routine something seemed, it was still worthy of gratitude. Gratitude is a lens for uncovering beauty.
So if I can suggest a how-to process, I’d recommend practicing gratitude where you’d least expect it to work. Select an unlikely target X, and then hold the thought, “I am grateful for X.” Eventually you’ll shift towards a more unconditional feeling of gratitude, and you’ll be able to drop that “for X.”
In practical terms I’ve found that as my gratitude has become more unconditional, my life circumstances improve to keep pace. These changes are very noticeable, like increases in my income or seeing my relationship with my kids improve. In keeping with the Law of Attraction, this is to be expected because if I’m grateful for everything in my life in advance, I should attract the circumstances that are congruent with those thoughts and feelings.
Level 1 Gratitude has its place, but if you want the universe to back up your feelings of gratitude with some actual results, eventually you need to progress to Level 2. When you’re living the life of your dreams, this is how you’re going to feel anyway, so why wait? Challenge yourself to create these feelings now, even in the most unlikely circumstances, and notice how you begin attracting the relationships, opportunities, and resources that resonate with those feelings.


January 22nd, 2007 at 1:14 pm
[…] The benefits are amazing. I’ve been doing this for two days, and already my mind is much more disciplined than it was before. I’m aware of little things that would have nagged me before, and now I drop them without a second thought. I’ve started developing a real sense of gratitude for life. Learning to control my mind in this way has opened the doors for potential. If I can make this big of a change in my thought patterns in two days, imagine what I can do when I really examine the processes of my mind. […]
January 22nd, 2007 at 4:49 pm
[…] Katie on the fence I read a great blog entry today on StevePavlina.com about gratitude. It really made me think about how I live my life. Is my gratitude dependent on circumstances? I don’t think so, but it’s definitely something to think about. I want to be a grateful person and not waver depending on what’s going on in my life. It’s a good article; worth reading. […]
January 31st, 2007 at 7:21 am
[…] Gratitude from Steve Pavlina–the man beta-testing the edge of the envelope so we don’t have to. […]
February 19th, 2007 at 12:30 pm
[…] It’s not a tool for manipulating the universe into giving you more material goods. Or I should say, according to some people, it is – but they’re interested in a completely different effect of gratitude than I am. If that’s the type of gratitude that you’re interested in – gratitude as a sort of universal ATM – well, more power to you, but you’re better off looking here. I am interested in current findings from the field of psychology and studies that show how having gratitude can create a significant, replicable improvement in people’s lives. […]
February 20th, 2007 at 10:04 pm
[…] Read the rest of Gratitude Be prosperous, […]
March 1st, 2007 at 8:09 pm
[…] I am very lucky with the law of attraction. I see it working in my life everyday. I started to do my research on the attitude of gratitude and found an article called Gratitude by none other than Steve Pavlina, who is on his way to becoming one of my favorite personal-development teachers, what can I say the guy is just good, and thorough. If you are in anyway interested in the role of gratitude in personal development and life you should read that article. But I digress, I believe that an attitude of gratitude will help boost positive change in your life and help in many other areas of your everyday life. So far I have seen its benefits in the following areas of my life: Stress Management Peace of mind – which has nothing to stress, at least for me. Self-control Better sleep Reduction in bad habits Creation of new health habits Better visualization Meditation Focus Going to the gym – I am so grateful for my membership that I do the one thing I thought was never going to be possible: pay for gym membership and actually go to the gym. […]
April 3rd, 2007 at 4:24 pm
[…] 1. Be grateful. Count each blessing that comes in your door and let them know how much you appreciate their presence. Try not to just be thankful you have students. Be grateful for their health and their willingness and their lives. Be grateful for your own health and abilities and the opportunity to interact with these people in a positive way. If you aren’t sure of the difference, you might check out what Steve Pavlina has to say about gratitude. Once you’ve stated the thought, “I am grateful for each of my students and their health and their fitness,” then treat them like you are grateful. Show them extra courtesy, provide as much personalized attention as you can, and go the extra mile to give them added incentive to always be in your class. It starts by acknowledging your gratitude, then sharing it with everyone. […]
April 16th, 2007 at 5:30 pm
[…] Steve Pavlina: Gratitude […]
May 11th, 2007 at 4:30 pm
[…] It’s not a tool for manipulating the universe into giving you more material goods. Or I should say, according to some people, it is – but they’re interested in a completely different effect of gratitude than I am. If that’s the type of gratitude that you’re interested in – gratitude as a sort of universal ATM – well, more power to you, but you’re better off looking here. I am interested in current findings from the field of psychology and studies that show how having gratitude can create a significant, replicable improvement in people’s lives. […]
July 9th, 2007 at 7:02 am
[…] Since putting to practice Steve Pavlina’s interesting and insightful article on gratitude I can say it was definitely worth the read. The article explains how to move from “Level 1″ gratitude, i.e being grateful and looking on the bright side, to “Level 2″ gratitude, essentially being grateful for the experience of life - a completely different experience. By practicing Level 2 gratitude it is possible to be grateful of everything, both the highs and lows, and enjoy it all. Any attempt to summarize would only be diluted; it really is one of those things worth reading, chewing, and digesting. […]